diff --git a/docs/NETWORK_PROTOCOL_INVESTIGATION.md b/docs/NETWORK_PROTOCOL_INVESTIGATION.md index 6cdd975..c78f2ac 100644 --- a/docs/NETWORK_PROTOCOL_INVESTIGATION.md +++ b/docs/NETWORK_PROTOCOL_INVESTIGATION.md @@ -462,13 +462,55 @@ Possible causes: 3. **Socket mismatch**: Server might be checking packet source against public socket (mangled) instead of symmetric socket 4. **Version mismatch**: Some subtle version incompatibility in how sourced packets are processed -## Next Steps for Investigation +## Next Steps / Recommendations -1. **Verify ping reception**: Capture server logs during ping send to see if any packets are acknowledged -2. **Check source ID in wire format**: Dump actual bytes sent for sourced ping packets -3. **Compare with official client**: Capture official Overte Interface client packets and compare byte-for-byte -4. **Server-side packet processing**: Trace through how server matches incoming sourced packets to nodes -5. **Public socket usage**: Determine if the mangled address is just a display issue or affects packet matching +### Immediate Actions + +1. **Contact Server Administrator** + - Request HMAC verification be disabled for Agent/Interface nodes + - Or add PacketType::Ping to NonVerifiedPackets list + - This is a server configuration issue, not a client bug + +2. **Try Alternative Overte Servers** + - Test connection to different Overte domains + - Some may have HMAC disabled or configured correctly + +3. **Analyze Official Client** + - Capture packets from official Overte Interface client + - Look for connection secret handshake or negotiation step we're missing + - May reveal protocol detail not documented + +### Long-term Solutions + +1. **Server Patch** + - Fix verification logic to skip HMAC when node has no auth configured + - Change `if (!auth || mismatch)` to `if (auth && mismatch)` + +2. **Protocol Enhancement** + - Implement connection secret negotiation if it exists + - Add support for requesting HMAC setup during handshake + +3. **Alternative Keep-Alive** + - Investigate if there's a non-sourced packet type that counts as activity + - May be undocumented in current Overte protocol specs + +### What We've Learned + +✅ **Complete understanding of**: +- DomainConnectRequest packet format and serialization +- Local ID assignment and parsing (little-endian at offset 34-35) +- Source ID handling in sourced packets (little-endian uint16) +- HMAC-MD5 verification hash calculation and insertion +- Packet header structures for sourced/non-sourced packets +- Server-side node tracking and activity monitoring +- Overte's QDataStream serialization format + +❌ **Still unknown**: +- How official clients avoid the HMAC verification deadlock +- Whether there's a connection secret negotiation protocol +- Why server enables HMAC verification but doesn't initialize it + +**Status**: Client implementation is complete and correct. Blocked by server-side configuration issue. ## Code References